The early reviews of the iPhone 5 have landed. The consensus: this is the best iPhone to date in just about every way, and it remains the best smartphone on the market.
Since we’re typically inundated with the “Which one should I get?” question immediately after an iPhone or iPad launch, here are my suggestions:
Color: The black model has black glass, a black finish on the aluminum, and a black band around the edge. If Batman had a Bat-smartphone, this would be it. The white model has white glass, a raw aluminum finish, and a silver band around the edge. Choose wisely.
Storage: If you take (and keep) tons of photos and videos without downloading them to a computer and clearing them off the phone, get a 32GB or 64GB. If you want to store several movies and TV shows along with your music, get a 32GB or 64GB. Otherwise, just get the 16GB. For the vast majority of people, 16GB is the way to go.
Carrier: I broke my AT&T contract and gave up unlimited data to switch to Verizon this time around (wish they would’ve paid me for the privilege). It made absolutely zero financial sense, but I’m through taking AT&T’s abuse. I had been holding out because of the simultaneous-voice-and-data issue, but AT&T’s coverage seems to have actually gotten worse in the last few months and it’s becoming a serious problem for business. When your commitment to clients is “Call our cell phones, we pick up”, you need your phone to actually ring when someone’s calling, and maintain a connection throughout the call. In other words, it needs to work like a phone.
Verizon’s LTE network is faster than AT&T’s and available in far more cities, and their voice coverage is second-to-none. Plus, I have a Verizon LTE iPad (which is amazing), and will be able to share a data plan between the two devices. So long, AT&T.
On to the reviews. I’ve pored through dozens of them, and hand-picked the best ones for your perusal. Enjoy:
John Gruber, Daring Fireball:
The iPhone 5 is really nice.
It feels great, looks great, has the best display I’ve seen at any size, runs noticeably faster, networks noticeably faster, is way thinner and lighter than any of its predecessors, takes better photos, and, in my six days of testing, gets totally decent iPhone-4S-level battery life.
But you don’t even have to turn it on to see how nice it is. Just hold it. You really have to.
David Pogue, New York Times:
At 0.3 inch, the phone is thinner than before, startlingly so — the thinnest in the world, Apple says. It’s also lighter, just under four ounces; it disappears completely in your pocket. This iPhone is so light, tall and flat, it’s well on its way to becoming a bookmark.
Jim Dalrymple, The Loop:
That has been my takeaway from the design of the iPhone 5 — small design changes that make for big user experience improvements. It’s important to remember that while the changes on the outside may be small to the naked eye, the changes on the inside are huge. Every major component of the iPhone has been changed in one way or another.
Scott Stein, CNET:
“This seems like a good time to discuss thumbs. As in, your thumb size and the iPhone 5. Going back to the iPhone 4S, I realized that the phone’s design has been perfectly aligned to allow a comfortable bridge between thumbing the Home button and stretching all the way to the top icon on the iPhone’s 3.5-inch display. That’s not entirely the case, now. I could, with some positioning, still thumb the Home button and make my way around the taller screen, but the iPhone 5′s a little more of a two-hander.”